Browse   Categories   General Discussio... » Composers & Composing    

Post New Reply
Forum
The heart of the MusBook.com community
General Discussion & Current Affairs » Composers & Composing

How do you like your Bach?

Topics: 43   Posts: 61

Do you like Bach? Most musicians do, but what sort performance do you think does his music most justice? Do you like it strict like Koopman, expansive like Stokowski, wayward like Glenn Gould, jazzy like Loussier, or (most controversially of all) on modern instruments like Chailly? And which performers would you like to see giving Bach a miss and sticking to the Vivaldi?


Topics: 3   Posts: 108

'Ah...Bach!'

The Bluffer's Guide to Music recommends, tongue-in-cheek, that 'Ah...Bach!' is all you need to say if a conversation veers in Bach's direction.

In a way, that is correct; it's hard to find words which adequately encompass his range and genius, or the sheer indestructibility of his music.

Bach is an all-weather composer, a man for all musical seasons, surviving exposure in unlikely venues and amidst unlikely musical bedfellows. Which other composer can be performed satisfactorily, according to individual taste, not only in the five ways Gavin lists, but also on a Moog Synthesizer, by the Swingle Singers, or in the style of Bobby McFerrin - and be an integral part of decades of cigar advertisements as well?!

Bach often used transcription, his own music appearing in different guises and reworked on different instruments. As a pianist, I find it fascinating when his music for violin, for instance, is presented pianistically by other composers: Busoni - the Chaconne; Rachmaninoff - the E Major Partita; or by Bach himself.

The current Grade 5 ABRSM Piano syllabus includes a movement from an unaccompanied violin sonata transcribed for keyboard by Bach. It's not too difficult, and it's quite short - but it is ravishing.

So how do I like my Bach? I like my Bach - transcribed.


______________________

Louise

Topics: 1   Posts: 5
Beautiful contribution, Louise! "The sheer indestructibility of his music": this is what I was thinking no longer than today, while also vaguely remembering that someone told me that Bach had been quite forgotten for some time (or hasn't he?).

Topics: 0   Posts: 7
Bach is the bed-rock of music for me, it makes no difference that my hands can no longer play him to my satisfaction. Bed-rock is bed-rock, just there for ever.

Topics: 6   Posts: 15
but Enid... the most fascinating question is... why? :)

Topics: 43   Posts: 61
I'm fascinated by the status of Bach in Soviet Russian culture. Basically, in the absence of officially sanctioned organised religion, he was elevated to the status of a god. And I think his reputation in the (now more or less secular) west is similar. I've visited the graves of many composers, but none had the same effect on me as visiting the grave of Bach in Leipzig. I found it very difficult to be confronted with physical evidence that such a legendary, almost mythical, composer existed at all. His works seem like they were handed down, fully formed and perfect from on high. And here is the grave of a short, fat, German organist bearing the inscription "J.S. Bach". I'm still not convinced he's in there.

Topics: 0   Posts: 55

I like Bach with inégal for buoyancy and rhythmic vitality.

If YouTube is anything to go by, Bach hasn't been forgotten yet.



Last night the top google YouTube Bach video, the Toccata and Fugue for Organ in D minor, had 5,882,111 views,

Tonight it has 5,894,474 views.


Topics: 0   Posts: 2
Bach may come in variable guise. The question is what is most "appropriate" to the music. In my view it is Gould with piano music and Harnoncourt with cantatas. Stokovski is to me more appropriate for cheerleaders.

Topics: 2   Posts: 17
Gould with piano music. Thomas, I like that.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Gv94m_S3QDo

Stokovski?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cdYXqiXH2jY
Where is the short, fat, German organist in this? Where is the humanity at all?



Topics: 2   Posts: 17
And where are the cheerleaders? Stokovski would be (would have been) flattered!


Page 1 out of 2 | <<<12>>>


Post New Reply


Sheet Music Download